The Great Smokies: From Natural Habitat to National Park
Part One

TITLE: The Great Smokies: From Natural Habitat to National Park – Part One
AUTHOR / REVIEWER: Jim Stokely
PERMISSION TO PUBLISH granted by author/reviewer, plus fair use to quote from and summarize Dan Pierce’s The Great Smokies: From Natural Habitat to National Park, The University of Tennessee Press, 2000.
In a 2025 blog post, historian Dan Pierce succinctly described his teaching career: “I started out as a 5th grade teacher, then a high school history teacher/coach (track and volleyball) for eight years. I’ve taught for the past 31 years in a university setting, most of that time at the University of North Carolina, Asheville. At UNC Asheville, I served as Chair of the History Department and in an endowed professorship as Distinguished Professor of the Mountain South.”
The son of a Baptist preacher, Pierce grew up in West Asheville. He earned his PhD in history from the University of Tennessee; his dissertation became The Great Smokies. This book is an excellent work of history because it both clarifies and reveals the political complexity surrounding the creation of the United States’ most visited national park.
In his introduction, Pierce states flatly that regional leaders of the park movement “reflected not so much love of the land as a desire to see the regional economy grow.” By the 1930s, this great forest of a half-million acres along the state line between Tennessee and North Carolina was diminishing due to (1) the extraction of “an estimated two billion board feet of lumber,” and (2) the chestnut blight, destroying a species “comprising 30 to 40 percent of the forest cover.” Ironically, logging railroads into the mountains made possible “the increasing popularity and profitability of tourism.”
Nationally, “a new idea of land use” was becoming popular in America. The “few national parks in existence captured the attention and the imagination of a sizable segment of the American population, quickly acquiring the status of national treasures” and “favored travel destinations for elite Americans” during the 1920s.
Pierce concludes that “The attitudes of area boosters dovetailed perfectly with the rise of the national park movement.” But the early national parks (Yellowstone and Yosemite, Glacier and the Grand Canyon), were all located in the sparsely populated West. The National Park Service’s first director, Stephen Mather, “knew that to solidify the position of the national parks in the hearts and minds of the American people, new parks would have to be more accessible.” These motivations led to the creation of the Southern Appalachian National Park Commission, “a special investigating committee to examine possible national park sites” in the Southern mountains.
As might be expected in the rough-and-tumble world of national politics, three states – North Carolina, Tennessee and Virginia – fought each other for the lion’s share of national park designation. “Both North Carolinians and Tennesseans were shocked,” Pierce writes, “when the committee recommended the Blue Ridge Mountains of Virginia as the ‘outstanding and logical place’ for a national park.” East Tennessee park advocate David Chapman “asserted that ‘hidden influences’ must be at work.” North Carolina Senator Furnifold Simmons and Tennessee Senator Kenneth McKellar advanced the spurned states’ claims in the U.S. Senate.
A mid-South version of geopolitics ran its natural course. “By early January [of 1925], National Park Service officials, Secretary [of the Interior Hubert] Work, and the members of the SANP Committee realized that the threats from disappointed boosters and their congressional delegates seriously jeopardized the project’s future. Unless they reached some sort of compromise, there would be no new national park in the Southern Appalachian region…On 11 January 1925, Secretary Work faced political reality and issued a press release calling for Congress to establish two national parks in the East.”
It would take about a decade for Shenandoah National Park and the Great Smoky Mountains National Park to be established.
